Smeraldina vs Vichy Catalan: Mineral Content, pH and Taste Compared
Smeraldina is a water from Sardinia, Italy. Its total dissolved solids are 155 mg/L, which is low minerality. Its pH is 6.59 (acidic). It contains 28.3 mg/L of sodium.
Vichy Catalan is a naturally sparkling spring water from Caldes de Malavella, Catalonia, Spain. Its total dissolved solids are 2,900 mg/L, which is very high minerality. Its pH is 8 (alkaline). It contains 1,097 mg/L of sodium.
What is the difference between Smeraldina and Vichy Catalan?
- Vichy Catalan carries about 19 times the dissolved minerals of Smeraldina (2,900 mg/L against 155 mg/L TDS), so it tastes fuller and more mineral.
- Vichy Catalan has the higher pH (8 against 6.59), which reads as softer and less sharp.
- Smeraldina is lower in sodium (28.3 mg/L against 1,097 mg/L).
- Smeraldina comes from Sardinia, Italy; Vichy Catalan comes from Caldes de Malavella, Catalonia, Spain.
Smeraldina and Vichy Catalan side by side
| Analysis | Smeraldina | Vichy Catalan |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Sardinia, Italy | Caldes de Malavella, Catalonia, Spain |
| Source | Not published | Not published |
| Source type | Not published | Spring |
| Carbonation | Not published | Naturally sparkling |
| pH | 6.59 | 8 |
| Total dissolved solids (TDS) | 155 mg/L | 2,900 mg/L |
| Calcium | 13.8 mg/L | 14 mg/L |
| Magnesium | 6.9 mg/L | 6 mg/L |
| Sodium | 28.3 mg/L | 1,097 mg/L |
| Potassium | 1.4 mg/L | 51 mg/L |
| Bicarbonate | 53.1 mg/L | 2,081 mg/L |
| Sulfate | 11.2 mg/L | 50 mg/L |
| Chloride | 49.8 mg/L | 584 mg/L |
| Silica | 18.3 mg/L | 15 mg/L |
| Nitrate | Not published | 1 mg/L |
| Minerality class | Low | Very high |
| pH class | Acidic | Alkaline |
| Virginality (sodium) | Potable | Potable |
| Hardness | Moderately hard (62.8 mg/L as CaCO₃) | Slightly hard (59.6 mg/L as CaCO₃) |
| Bottled since | Not published | Not published |
Which one to serve
- Smeraldina is light enough for delicate food: raw fish, fresh cheese, steamed vegetables and white wine.
- Vichy Catalan has the weight for rich food: steak, braises, fried dishes and aged cheese.
Smeraldina by the case
Vichy Catalan by the case
Sources
Every figure on this page is taken from the pages below. A figure nobody has published is shown as “Not published” rather than estimated. Mineral content varies slightly between bottlings.
Smeraldina
- https://acquasmeraldina.it/acqua/ — Brand site 'Le caratteristiche di Smeraldina' table, analysis by Università degli studi di Sassari dated 06/06/2023: residuo fisso a 180°C 155 mg/l, pH 6,59, bicarbonati 53,1, sodio 28,3, potassio 1,4, calcio 13,8, magnesio 6,9, cloruri 49,8, solfati 11,2, silice 18,3 mg/l. Nitrate not listed.
- https://kysela.com/smeraldina-still-water.html — Importer page could not be fetched (blocked) and brand domain did not resolve to a brand site; no analysis taken. All figures null.
Vichy Catalan
- https://finewaters.com/bottled-waters-of-the-world/spain/vichy-catalan — FineWaters analysis table: all mineral figures, pH, TDS, source type, region/place; FineWaters 'Established' year 1881 (not used for bottled_since). Brand's own site could not be fetched (blocked or no analysis published) unless listed below.
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vichy_Catal%C3%A1n — Carbonated mineral water from a thermal spring in Caldes de Malavella.













